Amish Cream Pie from M&M Cafe, Monticello

Comments (2)

Comment Feed

Amish Cream pie recipe error

Thanks for clarifying the recipe although I think it would turn out just fine w/the milk. But more half and half can't hurt! BTW I had clipped this wonderful recipe years ago when it first appeared in Isthmus and made it many, many times. But I lost it and couldn't quite remember it. I was astounded when I found it online! Thank you, thank you!

Mary 91 days ago

Amish Cream pie recipe error

It is 2 1/2 cups half and half. There is no whole milk in it. I make the pies at the M&M.

Anndre Bak 309 days ago


February 23, 2017


February 24, 2017


February 25, 2017


February 26, 2017


February 27, 2017


February 28, 2017


March 1, 2017

What to Do
* indicates required

  • What's happening this weekend

  • Bringing you the fun around town

  • A celebration of great beer