Amish Cream Pie from M&M Cafe, Monticello

Comments (2)

Comment Feed

Amish Cream pie recipe error

Thanks for clarifying the recipe although I think it would turn out just fine w/the milk. But more half and half can't hurt! BTW I had clipped this wonderful recipe years ago when it first appeared in Isthmus and made it many, many times. But I lost it and couldn't quite remember it. I was astounded when I found it online! Thank you, thank you!

Mary 93 days ago

Amish Cream pie recipe error

It is 2 1/2 cups half and half. There is no whole milk in it. I make the pies at the M&M.

Anndre Bak 311 days ago

Saturday

February 25, 2017

Sunday

February 26, 2017

Monday

February 27, 2017

Tuesday

February 28, 2017

Wednesday

March 1, 2017

Thursday

March 2, 2017

Friday

March 3, 2017

What to Do
LogosForSite.indd
* indicates required

  • What's happening this weekend

  • Bringing you the fun around town

  • A celebration of great beer